Stop Losing Black Friday Customers: Loyalty Program Strategies for 2025

Black Friday 2025 is almost here, and if you're planning to drive sales over this period it's important to start planning ahead now in preparation - the biggest & smartest brands will already be executing their Black Friday strategy.

Your biggest Black Friday problem isn't getting customers to buy—it's getting them to come back.

Last year, US consumers spent a record-breaking $10.8 billion online during Black Friday alone, with 87.3 million people shopping online and another 81.7 million hitting physical stores.

Yet here's the painful truth: most of those shoppers disappeared the moment the sale ended, never to return.

The Hidden Cost of Black Friday Success

Black Friday feels like a win when you see sales numbers spike. But what happens to customer lifetime value when 90% of your holiday shoppers never purchase again? You're essentially running a discount scheme for bargain hunters while your competitors build lasting relationships with your customers.

Here's what's really happening: You're spending heavily on advertising to attract price-sensitive shoppers who have zero brand loyalty. They'll buy your discounted products, then immediately start hunting for the next best deal— which is probably from one of your competitors.

With advertising prices increasing as more competitors enter the market, customer acquisition costs are rising every year, yet businesses continue to focus on attracting new customers instead of maximizing the value of existing ones. Meanwhile, loyalty program members typically spend 12-18% more per transaction and have a 5x higher lifetime value than non-members.

Your 2025 Black Friday Loyalty Strategy

The solution isn't to abandon Black Friday—it's to use it as a customer acquisition and retention powerhouse. Here's how to transform deal-hunters into loyal customers who drive revenue all year long.

Strategy 1: Make Your Loyalty Program Impossible to Ignore

During Black Friday chaos, your loyalty program needs to be front and center. With millions of first-time visitors flooding your store, this is your golden opportunity to convert bargain hunters into long-term customers.

Position your loyalty program prominently on your homepage, product pages, and checkout process. You can achieve this with Loyalty Wizard, offering built in components to easily design & build your own Shopify loyalty page. Don't just mention it—sell the value. Show potential members exactly what they'll earn from their Black Friday purchase and what rewards await them.

Train your customer service team to proactively mention loyalty program benefits during every interaction. When someone calls about a Black Friday deal, your team should end the conversation by explaining how joining your program will give them exclusive access to future sales and rewards.

For existing members, send targeted communications highlighting their special Black Friday perks. Use the customer data you've collected to create personalized offers that make members feel valued, not forgotten in the holiday rush.

Strategy 2: Leverage Early Access as Your Secret Weapon

Early access is the ultimate loyalty perk because it costs you nothing but delivers massive value to customers. In a world where popular Black Friday items sell out within hours, giving your loyalty members a 24-48 hour head start is incredibly valuable.

This strategy works on multiple levels. Members get first dibs on the best deals, avoiding the stress of items selling out. You get sales before your competitors even launch their promotions. Most importantly, members associate this exclusive access with real value, strengthening their emotional connection to your brand.

Structure early access in tiers to drive program engagement. Bronze members get 24-hour early access, Silver members get 48 hours, and Gold members get 72 hours plus exclusive items. This creates a clear incentive for customers to increase their engagement and spending to reach higher tiers.

Strategy 3: Remove Friction with Strategic Free Shipping

With 69% of Black Friday purchases happening on mobile devices, customers expect a seamless experience. Free shipping eliminates a major barrier and sweetens every deal without requiring additional discounts.

Make free shipping available to all loyalty members during Black Friday—even new sign-ups. This removes the common objection of "I'll wait until I have enough for free shipping" and encourages immediate purchases.

Consider tiered shipping benefits: standard free shipping for all members, expedited shipping for mid-tier members, and next-day delivery for your VIP customers. This approach protects the value of higher-tier benefits while still providing meaningful perks to all members.

Strategy 4: Expand Beyond Transactions

Black Friday brings massive traffic, but the real opportunity lies in engaging customers when they're not buying. Use this high-traffic period to introduce non-purchase ways to earn rewards.

Encourage customers to write reviews of their Black Friday purchases by offering bonus points. Set up social media challenges where customers share photos of their purchases for reward points. Create post-purchase surveys that help you understand customer preferences while giving members easy ways to earn rewards.

These activities keep customers engaged with your brand during the inevitable post-Black Friday lull. They also provide valuable data and user-generated content that supports your marketing efforts throughout the year.

Strategy 5: Target the Mobile-First Generation

Gen Z controls over $360 billion in spending power and represents the future of retail. But this generation expects brands to earn their loyalty continuously—not just during sales events.

Since 65% of Gen Z prefers mobile apps for loyalty program engagement, ensure your program works flawlessly on mobile. Create gamified experiences where customers can earn rewards for activities they already enjoy, like sharing content or referring friends.

Consider collaborative rewards where groups of friends can pool points toward exclusive merchandise or experiences. This taps into Gen Z's preference for social shopping while creating stronger program engagement through peer influence.

Measuring Success Beyond Black Friday Weekend

Your Black Friday loyalty strategy success shouldn't be measured just by weekend sales. Track these metrics to understand your real impact:

Customer Retention Rate: What percentage of Black Friday shoppers make a second purchase within 90 days?

Loyalty Program Sign-ups: How many new members joined during your Black Friday campaign?

Member vs Non-Member Spending: Compare average order values and lifetime value between loyalty members and regular customers.

Engagement Rates: Track how actively new members participate in your program after the initial signup.

The Year-Round Advantage

When you successfully convert Black Friday shoppers into loyalty program members, you're not just increasing immediate sales—you're building a foundation for consistent revenue growth. These customers will spend more per transaction, shop more frequently, and become advocates who refer new customers.

While your competitors scramble for new customers every holiday season, you'll have a growing base of engaged members who look forward to your exclusive offers and see value in staying connected to your brand.

The brands that thrive in 2025 won't be those with the deepest Black Friday discounts—they'll be the ones that use Black Friday as a strategic tool for building lasting customer relationships.

Stop losing customers to competitors—turn one-time buyers into lifetime revenue.

You've seen exactly how profitable loyalty programs transform retail businesses during Black Friday and beyond. While your competitors capture repeat purchases, are you still chasing expensive new customers every holiday season?

Loyalty Wizard For Shopify makes it effortless to build the loyalty program your customers actually want. Our complete Shopify solution includes everything you need: points systems, VIP tiers, referral rewards, and detailed analytics—all without the technical headaches.

Click here to Get started today 100% Free - No setup fees, no long-term contracts, no risk.